From the source rules
Who goes first in New York Slice?
Bezier Games English base rules, official Dized reference

The player who most recently won any game is the first Slicer. After that player divides the pizza, their left-hand neighbor chooses the first portion.
Rule details
The Slicer begins the round by revealing a pizza and Special, then dividing them into portions.
Portion choices proceed clockwise from the Slicer's left. The Slicer receives the last portion.
The player on the Slicer's left becomes the Slicer for the next round.
Source & edition
- New York Slice: Determine First SlicerBezier Games, official Dized rules · Determine First Slicer section of the official English online reference · Checked 2026-09-23
- New York Slice: 1. Start Each RoundBezier Games, official Dized rules · 1. Start Each Round section of the official English online reference · Checked 2026-09-23
- New York Slice: 2. Divide Pizza+Special Into PortionsBezier Games, official Dized rules · 2. Divide Pizza+Special Into Portions section of the official English online reference · Checked 2026-09-23
- New York Slice: 3. Choose A PortionBezier Games, official Dized rules · 3. Choose A Portion section of the official English online reference · Checked 2026-09-23
- New York Slice: 4. Next Player ChoosesBezier Games, official Dized rules · 4. Next Player Chooses section of the official English online reference · Checked 2026-09-23
- New York Slice: 5. Next Round & New SlicerBezier Games, official Dized rules · 5. Next Round & New Slicer section of the official English online reference · Checked 2026-09-23
Image: © Bezier Games · Bezier Games
If there’s a tie
The rulebook doesn’t say.
More starting rules
Browse available game rulesGames with a similar starting rule
Tawantinsuyu: The Inca EmpireWhoever harvested a vegetable most recently starts. Alternatively, use any random selection method the group chooses.
HorrifiedWhoever most recently ate garlic starts. Continue clockwise after each player's turn.
Flock TogetherThe person who most recently ate chicken goes last. The player to that person’s left goes first.
Portal: The Uncooperative Cake Acquisition GameThe player who most recently ate cake goes first.
HatsThe player who most recently ate a cookie starts the game.
Free game-night tools: score keeper · turn timer · dice roller · all tools
Found a different instruction in your edition? Send a correction with the game, edition, and source.