From the publisher’s rulebook
Who goes first in Toss Your Cookies?
English Gamewright rules
The person who most recently ate a home-baked cookie starts.
Source & edition
- Toss Your Cookies: Gamewright rulesGamewright · How to Play, PDF page 1 · Checked 2026-09-23
Image: © Gamewright (edition publisher) · Gamewright
If there’s a tie
The rulebook doesn’t say.
More starting rules
Browse available game rulesGames with a similar starting rule
HatsThe player who most recently ate a cookie starts the game.
Dinner in ParisThe person who most recently ate at a restaurant goes first.
Go Nuts!The person who most recently ate a nut starts.
Outfoxed!The person who most recently ate pie starts.
Chill Out!The person who most recently ate an ice cube starts.
Free game-night tools: score keeper · turn timer · dice roller · all tools
Found a different instruction in your edition? Send a correction with the game, edition, and source.