From the publisher’s rulebook
Who goes first in Watson & Holmes?
English publisher-hosted US rulebook, nine PDF spreads
The player with the best acting and reading voice reads the case introduction and takes the start-player token. If the group uses the recorded introduction instead, choose the starter randomly.
Rule details
The token holder chooses a location first in the Visiting Phase, followed clockwise by the others. This initial choice differs from later rounds, when the last player to obtain a location takes the token.
Source & edition
- Watson & Holmes: Ludonova rulesLudonova · Setup and Visiting Phase on printed page 9; Start Player Token on page 8 · Checked 2026-09-23Printed page references: 8, 9
Image: © Ludonova · Ludonova
If there’s a tie
The rulebook doesn’t say.
More starting rules
Browse available game rulesGames with a similar starting rule
The Lord of the Rings: The Card GameChoose a first player and give them the first-player token. If the group cannot decide, select the first player randomly.
Loco MomoThe player who most recently walked in a forest starts; the group may instead choose the starter at random.
Neuroshima Hex! 3.0The game owner starts as Player 1, but may choose another starting player; the group may also choose the starter randomly.
The Siege of RunedarThe shortest player starts, or choose the starter randomly.
ChrominoThe youngest player begins, or the group may choose the first player randomly.
Free game-night tools: score keeper · turn timer · dice roller · all tools
Found a different instruction in your edition? Send a correction with the game, edition, and source.